Ibarra-Hurtado et al. 2009 [17]
|
12
| |
CT (4 and 1 preop weeks)
|
Mean 13.9 cm
|
6 direct closure+6 anterior MCM
|
None (mean FU 9 mo, 4–18)
|
Elstner et al. 2016 [9]
|
32
|
14 weeks preop
|
CT (preop, 2 mo Pop, 6 mo Pop)
|
5 × 9 cm to 24–27 cm
|
26 direct closure w/mesh reinforcement +6 anterior MCM
|
None (mean FU 19 mo - 5–39)
|
Chavez-Tostado et al. 2014 [7]
|
14
|
mean 40.1 preop days
|
CT (4 and 1 preop weeks)
|
Mean 14.6 cm (282 cm2)
|
11/14 direct closure, 3/14 MCM, both w/mesh reinforcement
|
None (mean FU 34 mo – 18–120)
|
Rodriguez-Acevedo et al. 2018 [4]
|
56
|
7–14 days preop
|
CT (preop, 10 days post TB injection, mo Pop, 2 and 6 mo Pop)
|
Mean 11.6 cm (5 × 9 to 28 × 19 cm)
|
48/56 direct closure, 8/56 MCM, both w/mesh reinforcement
|
One (questionable)
|
Nielsen et al. 2019 [12]
|
37
|
3–4 weeks preop
|
CT
|
Mean 12 × 20 cm
|
22/37 direct closure, 15/37 MCM, both w/mesh reinforcement
|
Not reported
|
Zielinski et al. 2013 [14]
|
18
|
Pre-closure (open abdomen)
|
None
|
Not described
|
83% primary closure, 9/18 MCM
|
11% recurrence, 6% mortality
|